I'm not much of a cinema crier. I generally have something of a patronizing view of the people sniffling in the row behind me. I certainly didn't go into this film expecting to be moved anywhere close to tears, but as the lights went up at the end of the film I was the one with red-rimmed eyes and a tissue surreptitiously wiping off my running mascara.
Tonight was the world première of Little Ashes and I was very proud to be there. It's the story of Salavdor Dali and the relationship he may or may not have had with the poet Frederico Garcia Lorca. I think its easy to be fooled by the fact these are famous figures, or the difficult political climate of the setting, at its core this is a love story with a tragedy so far beyond Romeo and Juliet.
I can't imagine it is easy for any of us to imagine a fascist Spain where homosexuality is a death-worthy sin, I couldn't before the film started but the filming and the quality of acting is so far beyond anything I hoped for and I was transported immediately. At no point from beginning to end did I feel detached from the action, I felt every second.
I will not give too much of the story away but those of you who know about the lives of Salvador Dali and Frederico Garcia Lorca will probably have a good idea how it goes.
The passion between Robert Pattinson playing Dali and Javier Beltran as Lorca is wonderful, when they are happy you can't help but smile with them and when they are tense you will be gripping the armrests of your chair. The secondary performances by Marina Gattel and Matthew McNulty were also superb, this is not a film where any one character shines, every character is played with a drive and an understanding that is missing from most mainstream productions.
I have two favourite scenes which I thought captured the torturous and yet exciting feelings that the leads were successfully attempting to portray. The first is when they were riding bicycles and playing on the beach, the ease the fun in there relationship before they had crossed the physical line was picture perfect romance, truly heartwarming even though the whole time you knew it could never end well. My second favourite scene is when Lorca goes to visit Dali in a hotel 8 years after they parted under awkward circumstances. You can actually feel Lorca's pain at seeing Dali hide under affections and exaggerated eccentricity and at the same time feel Dali's need to just push his guard down and grab the only person he's every really loved.
The final scene of Dali with the black paint (no I wont go into any more detail than that it would ruin it!) is cinematic genius, so powerful and moving.
It's marvellous. I want to watch it again and I suggest you look out for it.
-
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 07:46:53
-
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 08:03:16
Can I also add my thanks. I've been searching the web for any crumb of information on the premiere and was lucky enough to find your excellent piece. Many thanks. If you a follow up (even more indepth review) I'd love to know what you thought of the accents used.
-
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 09:04:40
Again thanks from me for this beautifully writen report.
-
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 10:07:05
Thank you for writing up a eport so quickly. As a fan of Rob Pattinson I really appreciate it. Jealous you saw it but also very pleased for you.
-
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 12:17:46
Hi
I would love your views on this blogers review of the film.
http://stephaniescaife.blogspot.com/2008/10/my-review-of-little-ashes.html
It seems so different from your wonderful report. -
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 12:48:59
I did write that review quite quickly as I wanted to get some information across to fans as quickly as I could but I will happily write a more in-depth review if fans would post questions here. I will also read and give my response to the review Wendy posted a link to.
So please ask as many questions as you would like! -
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 13:50:26
Hi, great review, but please make sure you note that you have contained spoilers for some people. And, keep this in mind if you feel the need to write a more indepth review. Reviews usually contain commentary on themes and such - not give away information about the events of the film.
-
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 14:20:48
Wow, RomanceReader, that´s very nice of you!
Thanks for your wonderful review so far.
Would you please describe the "under water-scene". I thought I read about it, and now I´m very curious!!
Thanks a lot!! -
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 19:25:22
Thanks so much for this review. I'm anxiously awaiting any chance to see this movie ~ I appreciate you sharing, and would love to hear more.
-
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 19:42:06
Hey, this is so generous of you to answer our questions... i was just wondering... if you saw Brokeback Mountain, and how you would compare Little Ashes to that, or if the two movies were very different. I can't wait to see this movie!
-
- Wednesday, 08. Oct, 2008 @ 19:49:00
I'm sorry Kaitlyn I've never seen Brokeback Mountain (I know I've been living in a cave right?) so I can't comment on that one! I'm sure there will be comparisons so I might just have to watch it so I can make my own! I probably wont be able to do that tonight though as I'm a law student with a massive backlog but I'll get on to it soon!
-
- Thursday, 09. Oct, 2008 @ 02:22:26
I really enjoyed reading your review.. I was just wondering if you happened to be sitting in the second row from the back because I was there at the premiere also and I talked to another American there and was just wondering if it was you!
-
- Thursday, 09. Oct, 2008 @ 03:37:06
I apologize; I just assumed you were American for no reason at all, but looking back at my comment I realized that you might not be, and now I see that you live in London.. so, my apologies!
-
- Thursday, 09. Oct, 2008 @ 11:16:33
Hi
Many thanks for being generous with your time. On IMDB and the TMF site there are reviews which say Rob's accent slipped. Were you aware of this. I noticed one person had responded to the criticism as follows:
"I don't know what expectation others had of this film, but mine were exceeded. It was only towards the end that Robert's accent slipped but I justified that as deliberate in that by then he was supposed to have spent a chunk of time in the US and other countries."
I am interested to read your views on this and whether there is a need for Rob to redo some of the vocals.
-
- Thursday, 09. Oct, 2008 @ 11:27:53
I forgot to ask you if you thought the film length was about right. There was some talk that the end needed some editing. Here's a quote from IMDB
"just felt that there were moments that could have been tightened up a bit, especially near the end. At one point I thought the film had reached a natural conclusion and was almost waiting for the credits, but then came another finalish (pardon the English) scene, followed by the final scene. This may have been a director issue."
Again I'm very interested to hear your views on this. -
- Wednesday, 15. Oct, 2008 @ 14:01:30
Just to repeat on this entry too that my understanding is that Rob's accent changes were intentional.
-
- Saturday, 18. Oct, 2008 @ 00:44:20
Thanks for the great review. Im a huge Rob fan so this made my day. It's really annoying me that some lucky people have already seen it and the rest of us have yet to even see a trailer! They promised us a trailer ages ago and still...nothing. I litterally can't wait to see this film and it makes me sad that I probably will never get to see it unless they release it on DVD. I live in Ireland so the chances of my country showing it are very small. Anyway, so a quick question: are the sex scenes very creepy? Or are they sweet? I had to change the channel during the sex scene when I watched Brokeback mountain lol.
-
- Saturday, 18. Oct, 2008 @ 00:54:04
I haven't seen the movie, so I couldn't really tell you if Rob's accent changes were on purpose or a harmless mistake.
If he is the excellent actor that I think he is, then they were probably on purpose, to convey Dali spending a number of years away from his home.
But after seeing the Twilight trailer, it's come to my attention that Rob's american accent slipped a tad (not much, just a little) so perhaps his spanish accent slipped a bit too. This can happen to the best of actors (except James McAvoy, who seems to be able to do any accent haha)
So really its a toss of the coin. It could be either.
I know that Rob took his role of Dali very very seriously, he became obssessed with Dali and did all the research he possibly could (unless he's lying lol).
He also said that Dali was the first role he did that required some serious thought.
I believe that Rob is a smart complex guy, and he could have EASILY have come up with the idea to make his accent flawed in the final scene after 8 years. Rob seems like the type of serious actor who would do something like that. -
- Wednesday, 04. Feb, 2009 @ 05:12:48
I haven't seen the movie yet, I was a little surprised by the casting of the "Twilight" teen idol as Dali. Oh don't get me wrong, I have no idea if Robert Pattinson is a good actor or not, my point is that he seems much to good looking to play Dali.
Salvador Dali really wasn't that attractive in a traditional sense, and I always thought that was what made him the strange, eccentric and genius artist that he was.
This is just my opinion but, would audiences like the movie as much if it wasn't being played by good looking actors, as opposed to an actor that looked more like the real person, just not a heart throb???? Do you think we will see Brad Pitt as Vincent Van Gogh next???
-
- Wednesday, 11. Feb, 2009 @ 10:29:40
I have a question. Do you have any information about date of release this film? On DVD or wide screen. It is desirable to know about russian premier. I want to see this film very much!!! I have seen the movies with Robert Pattinson and I think he is a very good actor. His role in Twilight is just a lucky ticket for him. And rather casual.
-
- Monday, 20. Apr, 2009 @ 01:30:06
At that time homosexuality was a death-worthy sin worldwide, not only in Spain. The name of the Spanish poet is Federico Garcia Lorca

As an avid Pattinson fan can I thank you for such a wonderful review. I'm so glad you enjoyed the film. Would you be happy to answer some fan questions? We are all dying to see the film but it will be ages before many of us have an opportunity to see it so any information on the film is vlauable to us.